The notion of “illinibucks” in
theory sounds like an interesting concept but in actually would be difficult to
implement in my opinion. Our current process utilizes a system in which we
prioritize by a first come first serve basis, by seniority, or different
colleges of study. I believe that our current system is fair because we place
emphasis on taking the initiative such as waiting in line. The implementation
of illinibucks would seem to promote greater utility but would be hard to carry
out because I believe that there would be many conflicting attitudes towards
this type of system. For example, one problem illinibucks would create would be
to make it unfair towards people that are very active and involved. These are
people that register for their classes at their earliest convenience or arrive
ahead of time in order to wait in a line. These people would be at a
disadvantage because they would have the same priority as someone that would
normally not take the initiative to do these things.
Furthermore, illinibucks would make
it incredibly difficult for upperclassmen to for major specific people to
select the classes that they need to take. Under our current system, we place
priority for people that need to take these classes. If everybody had
illinibucks, anybody would be able to have an early selection for a class that
they hypothetically would not need. The benefits to illinibucks would be create
more efficiency when it comes to consumer decisions. Consumers would be smarter
about dedicating their resources by using illinibucks. They would have to
consider what specific things they value such as waiting for a class or waiting
in line for a football ticket. Lines would invariably be smaller or more well-organized
because consumers would not spend unnecessary illinibucks for things that they
don’t need.
If I were given the opportunity to
use illinibucks I would utilize my illinibucks primarily for important things
such as school. I would make sure to allocate my illinibucks to selecting
classes or meeting with my academic advisors first before I would use them for extracurricular
such as buying tickets to sporting events. I could see potentially problems
arising from the process of allocating illinibucks. Would students be given the
same amount of illinibucks per semester? Could students buy more illinibucks if
they needed them? Problems could arise because people could see some injustices
from people being able to afford to buy more illinibucks. How would the school
deal with students that don’t have the money to buy additional illinibucks?
Would they get less priority for important things such as selecting classes?
The transfer pricing of illinibucks would create many issues depending on if
the administered price was either too low or too high. As mentioned before, if
the administered price was too high then students that are unable to buy these
illinibucks would be at a disadvantage. If prices were administered too low,
then consumers could see problems arising from too many people having priority
over others. These would create longer lines and consumers would see the
illinibucks as being useless because people would be able to afford more of
them.
You seem to like the seniority based system. But wouldn't it work out that students have more uniform access to classes every semester if there were an Illinibucks system in place?
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that it would be inequitable if students could buy Illinibucks. But that need not happen. Students could simply have an allocation each semester, with no carry over from one semester to the next and use them that way.
I like your point about the negative side effects to students who are already active and involved. There would be a disincentive to be as active and involved if you could get the same benefits from IlliniBucks and without as much work.
ReplyDeleteYour point about upperclassmen not being able to get into the classes they need is interesting. I'd be interested to know if this is a problem now - do classes that are required for specific majors fill up quickly and exclude underclassmen that register later? There are underclassmen in the honors programs that sign up before non-honors seniors - do they take spots that seniors would benefit from having now?